iPhone 4 – Which plan, which carrier?

I don’t think it’s as big as buying a house, however choosing an iPhone plan is a big financial decision. You see you are locked in for at least...

I don’t think it’s as big as buying a house, however choosing an iPhone plan is a big financial decision. You see you are locked in for at least a year, if not two years in most cases.

What if the carrier you choose has a bad network in your area, but you don’t know that because you don’t use them now!

How much data will you use?

For a full list of iPhone plans – view my data page here

These are all difficult questions, continue reading for my personal thoughts on the plans all released today.

So, first, my personal position.

I’ve been with Optus for over 13 years – pretty sure it’s more like 15, but their records don’t go back that far, so I can’t find out!

I’ve got no complaints about their service, or their coverage.  There are two blackspots which annoy me, first on the Pacific Highway near Lindfield, the other on Beecroft Road off the M2 just north of the M2 – 100% guaranteed drop out, 50-100meters only. Then it’s all good.

With Data, I’ve not noticed any huge speed issues, I mean really, it’s not like we’re doing full combat multi-player gaming on our phones.  Downloading emails and surfing the web is fine, on all carriers.

I signed up to a two year contract 25 months ago.  For the SOLE purpose of getting an iPhone (3G).  I hated it, couldn’t use it, preferred the Blackberry.  Gave it to my wife.

About 3 months ago, knowing the iPhone 4 was coming, I switched my plan back to allow data, and got going on my iPhone 3G again.  I started to really get into the games, the apps, my sleep tracker is important to me!  iOS4 upgrade has crippled me – it’s really quite slow (Update – I have done NOTHING to try and fix this, so will investigate this if others are experiencing same.  I’ve had several comments on Twitter saying they have not experienced this).

So, why am I even looking for an iPhone plan?  Simple – I want an iPhone 4.  Will I stick with it for 24 months, perhaps, perhaps not – we’ll see about that soon.

Until this week, I was almost convinced I would sign up with Telstra, better network, best network in fact, for coverage most importantly – everywhere, city and rural.  Both Optus and Vodafone stuggle outside the metro areas I’ve found, especially with 3G.

However today’s announcement from Telstra disappointed.  I am on a $79 cap now.  I’d be keen to stay at that area (or less!)

Most of my monthly bills are $90-95 with excess calls added up.

With Telstra, $79 would give me 500 Mb of  data on the iPhone – is that enough.  Right now – yes.  In 2 years? who the heck knows?  What sort of apps and data might I be doing?  If I want to tether it to my computer, that’s certainly not enough.

So, With a $99 cap offering still just 500 Mb, but additional call and text inclusions, I think that’s still not enough.

Vodafone offers me Unlimited Calls, Texts and 3Gb of data at $99 a month.  That’s more than I want now, and remember, sign up for a BIG plan, and you can’t go DOWN.  Sign up to a lower plan, you can certainly go up.  So, perhaps Vodafone’s $69 cap, with 1.75 Gb and $650 in calls and texts looks like a viable option.

Ruling out Three (sorry, I just can’t do it!), that brings me finally to Optus.  At $99, I can get 5 Gb of data, and Unlimited Calls and Texts.

One step down, $89, I can get Unlimited calls and text’s, plus 3Gb data.

Taking the ‘sign up low, increase later’ approach, I can sign up at $59, with $550 worth of calls, and 2Gb data.

The key here is to think about the LIFE of the contract.

So, here’s my plan.  Sign up on Friday to Optus.  2 years.  $59 Plan.  iPhone comes at $0 (16Gb phone).  Then, I monitor my call and data usage, and upgrade to the $89 if Needed to keep my calls and texts under control.

The second place option is Vodafone at $49, the 16Gb phone though comes at $5 per month. If I was to upgrade during the life of the contract I’d go to the $99 unlimited call and text plan.  Problem is that extra $10 on the bigger plan, the $5 per month on the handset (Optus and Voda are both $10 per month at the plans mentioned here for the iPhone 4 32Gb).  Main problem, I don’t KNOW the network.  I’ve heard enough bad things to make me feel like I’ll have the same experience as I do now with the Optus Network.

Optus have been spruking for some time their ‘network upgrades’.  Call me naive, but  I’m going to trust them.  Fingers crossed.

For what it’s worth, I think overall Optus have taken ownership of this space.  A HUGE range of plans, 12 and 24 months, some really ‘marketable’ plans which will be attractive to passing buyers.

Telstra have missed the mark.  Disappointing given their excellent new broadband and customer service commitment of late.

Time will tell if I’ve made the right decision.

Let me know what you think!

Categories
Opinion

Trev produces two of the most popular technology podcasts in Australia, Your Tech Life and Two Blokes Talking Tech. He hosts a nightly radio show on Talking Lifestyle, 8pm Monday to Friday in Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane, appears on over 50 radio stations across Australia weekly, and is the Tech Expert on Channel 9’s Today Show and A Current Affair. Father of three, he is often found down in his Man Cave. Like this post? Buy Trev a drink!
9 Comments on this post.
  • Tweets that mention iPhone 4 – Which plan, which carrier? | Your Tech Life — Topsy.com
    28 July 2010 at 12:06 am
    Leave a Reply

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Trevor Long, Your Tech Life. Your Tech Life said: and the winner is… @optus – after much deliberation – http://bit.ly/9bQ4Ye – tell me if i'm wrong in the comments.. […]

  • Jeloz
    27 July 2010 at 1:34 pm
    Leave a Reply

    no one using an iPhone on Optus has anything good to say about them……
    They stole so much of the market for iPhone at the start , did they ever recover.
    I have used all 3 networks and i chose Voda because of cost – $114 unlimited calls but at least once a week I pine for the NextG speed but the $500 a month i would get charged keeps me with Voda….

  • trevorlong
    27 July 2010 at 1:36 pm
    Leave a Reply

    I hear you – I've heard all the reports. Perhaps because I've only used the iPhone REALLY in the last 3 months… I havent seen it?

    Or I'm blinded to it all!

  • James Cheeseman
    27 July 2010 at 1:51 pm
    Leave a Reply

    whats so wrong with 3?

  • trevorlong
    27 July 2010 at 1:53 pm
    Leave a Reply

    It's quite rude really isn't it.. Simple, I've never used them for any length of time, and frankly, they are now owned by Vodafone, so any network advantage exists on both – so, the Vodafone plans are what I looked at..

  • Deckland
    27 July 2010 at 2:24 pm
    Leave a Reply

    Well I work in mining, so for the remotness of site (I'm about 120 KM north-west of Newman in WA), I have to go with Telstra… iPhone 3Gs, on a $15 plan for calls (Oh, I purchased the phone outright from Apple, so I wasn't locked to any network), and the $79 6gb data plan, as I tether the laptop and access the net that way (right now in fact), and this works for me as I make very few calls on the phone… we're on Optus at home, and my wife has an Optus iPhone, both of those plans give effectively unlimited calls, so she calls me when we talk. This is a solution which works for us. My bill for the month is always around the $95 ish mark, so that's working for us. At this stage I'm not looking to move to an iPhone 4.

  • trevorlong
    27 July 2010 at 2:27 pm
    Leave a Reply

    Importantly mate, you KNOW what is happening, and you know what you need, so when you do want to contract, you're in a great position. Key though – you're rarely going to match that NextG network, its an absolute winner..

  • Andrew E
    28 July 2010 at 6:19 am
    Leave a Reply

    Some good points raised.
    I live right near that blackspot in Lindfield and I had a bad 2 years with optus on the iPhone.
    I totally agree that the iOS 4 upgrade cripples performance on the “3g” iphone.
    I have recently switched to Telstra (HTC Desire) and I have noticed its network performance is much better.
    I had full 3g reception in Nyngan! (700km from Sydney)
    Another point. If you don't plan on tethering, 200-500MB of data is more than enough… And I suspect Telstra will drop data prices soon anyway.

  • Pooly
    29 July 2010 at 5:50 am
    Leave a Reply

    Everyone I know has had the same problem with the iOS4 software upgrade – it's extremely frustrating! I too have been a long term Optus customer but plan to switch to Telstra for the better network coverage they provide.

  • Leave a Reply

    *

    *